Presumptive Taxation Scheme: Budget 2023

Income Tax Income from Business or Profession
1

Section 44AD and 44ADA were primarily introduced to provide relief to small taxpayers from the tiring and complicated process of maintenance of accounts and getting them audited.

As per section 44AD, any individual, HUF, or Partnership firm (other than LLP), having annual turnover of up to ₹2 crores, can declare 6% or 8% of its turnover or actual profits whichever is higher as taxable income.

Similarly, as per section 44ADA, a professional with gross receipts up to ₹50 lakhs, can declare 50% of their gross receipts or actual profits whichever is higher as taxable income.

In Budget 2023, FM Nirmala Sitharaman has proposed enhanced limits under both these sections to ease compliance for MSMEs and professionals, as under:

The turnover limit under section 44AD has been increased to ₹3 crores from the earlier ₹2 crores, and for professionals, the gross receipts have been increased to ₹75 lakhs from the earlier ₹50 lakhs under section 44ADA. This is applicable from FY 2023-24/AY 2024-25 onwards.

Note: These enhanced limits come with a condition that the amounts received in cash should not exceed 5% of the total turnover or gross receipts in that financial year.

Let’s understand the above-proposed amendment with the help of certain examples.

Example 1: Dr. Mehta is a practicing MBBS, having annual gross receipts of ₹73,00,000. Out of the total gross receipts Dr. Mehta received ₹5,00,000 Lakhs by way of cash.

Solution: In this case, though gross receipts are lower than the enhanced limit of ₹75 Lakhs, Dr. Mehta can not opt for Presumptive Taxation as the amount received in cash (i.e, ₹5,00,000) exceeds 5% (i.e, ₹3,65,000) of his total gross receipts.

Example 2: Mr. Shah who is involved in a trading business has an annual total turnover ₹2.8 Crore, out of which the amount received in cash is ₹10 Lakhs.

Solution: In this case, the turnover is less than the enhanced limit of ₹3 crore, so Mr. Shah can opt for presumptive taxation scheme, since the amount received by him in cash (₹10 lakhs) is less than 5%(ie, ₹14 lakhs) of the annual total turnover .

Calculation of Mr. Shah’s income:

Total turnover = ₹2.8 crore

  • Non-cash turnover = ₹2.7 crore * 6%= ₹16.2 lakhs
  • Cash turnover = ₹10 lakhs * 8% = ₹80K

Therefore, total Taxable Income= ₹16.2 lakhs + ₹80K = ₹17 Lakhs
Calculation of tax liability as per both the regimes as per budget 2023:

image
image846×625 45.5 KB

Have doubts? Comment below!

4 Likes
2

I am a practicing doctor, majority of my receipts are in cash but my gross receipts are less than Rs. 50 lakhs. Can I opt this presumptive taxation scheme?

3

Hi @Swapnil_Agarwal,

The condition of cash receipts not exceeding 5% of the gross receipts is applicable only on the enhanced limits of ₹75 Lakhs, so you can opt for presumptive taxation scheme even if your cash receipts exceeds 5% of the gross receipts with total receipts not exceeding ₹50 lakhs.

Hope this helps!!

4 Likes
4

Hello Niyati, I am working as freelancer for a foreign client. My income would be 60L approximately. Since the income exceeds the limit of 50L but less than 75L can I still opt for sec 44ADA? I have no other source of income.

5

Hi @Ishwar,

Yes, you can opt for Sec 44ADA as your income is less than ₹75 Lakhs. The enhanced limits are applicable for the FY 2023-24. Also you will have to check that your cash receipts don’t exceed 5% of the gross income from Freelancing.

Hope this helps!!

1 Like
6

Thanks for your reply. I don’t earn any money in form of cash.

7

Hi @Ishwar,

Since you won’t be earning any money in form of cash you can opt for Sec 44ADA

1 Like
8

Hi @CA_Niyati_Mistry. Thank you so much for your time.

I successfully filed my taxes under 44ADA for AY 22-23. I want to file my tax for AY23-24 now. I have two major questions.

  1. For AY23-25, do I have to pay advance tax (100% of my total tax) by 15th March 2023 or 2024? Which year?
  2. If I have to pay it by 15th March 2023, I should go to the income tax website and pay advance tax for AY23-24. But I distinctly remember that for AY22-23, I could file my tax from the normal File Income Tax section where I could select section ADA and fill my information and the website would calculate my tax for me. But when opting for advance tax this year I do not see any such options.

Cleartax has this to say.

Further, anyone opting for this scheme is not bound by the mandate of maintaining books of accounts too. While he is also liable to file his return by 31 July of the assessment year, he must file his return in ITR 4.

They say I have to file it by 31st July 2024. What am I missing? Again thank you for your time!

9

@CA_Niyati_Mistry I have a thread about this topic here now.

On further research I realised I misunderstood quite a few things.

Please correct me if I’m wrong!

Income tax filing and Advance payment are completely different things. You pay advance tax before 15th March of the financial year and then file your income tax returns in the Assessment year.

Okay it makes sense now. I will make the following assumptions for my timeline. Please let me know if I am correct.

  1. For my FY22-23 income, I should go to the income tax website and pay my estimated advanced tax for the income I earned between 1st April 2022 and 31st March 2023 under AY23-24. Because I’m eligible for 44ADA, I have the benefit of paying it all in one go before March 15th 2023 instead of paying it in instalments.

  2. Then before 31st July 2023, I will have to file my income tax return. Neutral case - I won’t have to pay anything when filing my ITR because my estimated advanced tax payment was correct. Worst case - I have to file any difference and pay some more. Best case, my advance tax payment was more and I get a refund.

Are the dates mentioned correct? Are my assumptions right? Thanks again for your time.

10

Hi @Vivek_Negi,

Yes, the dates mentioned and the assumptions are correct. Income Tax Return filing and Advance Tax payment are two different concepts. While you file ITR after the PY 2022-23 ends till 31st July, Advance tax is the tax liability that you pay before the year ends. In case of 44ADA only one installment of Advance tax is applicable i.e 15th March where you pay the entire estimated tax liability in one go.

At the time of return filing the income will be calculated again and thus tax liability might differ from what you had determined earlier at the time of Advance tax payment. In case you have paid excess Advance Tax you will receive refund and in case of deficiency you will have to pay tax along with interest.

Hope this clarifies!

1 Like
11

so . whether i opt for presumptive or non-presumptive ; advance tax has to be paid as pet the % slabs and as per the dates ! am i right ?

12

Hi @HIREiN

Advance tax is to be paid if the estimated tax liability exceeds ₹10,000 in a financial year, irrespective of whether presumptive taxation is opted for or not.

Hope this helps.

13

Hi

I work for a foreign client and approximate total invoicing would be for around 1.2Cr

Is it wise to work as an individual or form an entity?

14

Hi @ankurs,

44AD/ADA can only be opted by Individuals, HUF and Partnership firm (other than LLP). If you wish to continue opting 44AD/ADA, to work as an Individual would be wiser.

Hope this helps!

15

Hi thank you for the detailed explanation.

I am a freelance software developer with income 30L in FY22-23

My professional expenses are 10L

Can I opt for this scheme? What would be taxable amount in that case?

16

Yes, you can opt for the presumptive scheme, the taxability would be implied on ₹20 Lakhs at slab rates.

Hope this helps.

17

Hey @CA_Niyati_Mistry
Thank you very much for your detailed explanation about PTS.

I would really appreciate if you take time to solve my query.

I am a freelancer and I am earning money from international clients only.
My yearly turnover is around 30L. I do website designing, software dev. and digital marketing.
I do outsource some of my work to local freelancers.

I have been filing ITR for over 3 years under 44AD and I am selecting 21008 (Other service n.e.c.)
I am showing profit of around 10% (actual may be between 20-40%) of my turnover and so I am not paying tax as my income is below 5L.

My questions to you is

  1. Can IT Dept. ask to explain about my expense which is 90% of my turnover?
  2. Is it OK to pay local freelancers in cash (I always pay up to 10K INR max)?
  3. I am having GST and had filed LUT and so I am paying 0 GST. Does GST dept. ask for FIRC doc?
  4. What else can be shown to GST dept. in case I need to prove that the income I received had been sent by foreign client?
  5. Is it ok to choose 21008 (Other service n.e.c.) under 44AD? If not what should be code under 44AD?

Thank you very much in advance.

18

What if in future my income exceeds 75L then can I file tax under section 44AD?

19

Hi @love4u_now,

The answer to your questions are as follows:

  1. Generally IT Dept will not ask you to explain the 90% of your expenses. But in case they do you can take references from Case Laws where it was held that if the taxpayer has opted for 44AD/ADA he is not required to maintain books of accounts nor the IT Dept shall ask for the same.
  2. It is always advisable to pay business related expenses through banking channels.
  3. Since you’ve filed LUT and you are not paying any GST, the Dept may ask for FIRC document to make sure if you have received the export proceeds in time.
  4. You can show the Purchase order details or any contract if you have entered into with the Foreign clients for providing Freelancing services. Also you can show the bank statement in which the payment is received.
  5. Ideally, you are a Freelancer which means you are providing services as professional. Section 44ADA is for professionals those provide services where you have to declare 50% of your total receipts or actual profits whichever is higher as your income and calculate tax accordingly. Also the code selected is correct but the section 44AD is not correct.

Hope this helps!

20

Hi @Ishwar,

In future if your income exceeds ₹75 Lakhs then you cannot file tax return under section 44ADA. Then it will be treated as Regular business income where calculations will be made for profits by deducting purchases and expenses from your sales.

Also, if you opt out of the Presumptive Taxation Scheme, you can not opt for the same for the next 5 Financial years.

Hope this helps!