Tax audit u/s 44AB: Who is it appliable to?

:spiral_calendar: Due date reminder: 30th September 2024 is the due date for filing the audit report for AY 2024-25.

If you run a business or earn professional income, you’ll likely have numerous transactions, both for payments received and expenses incurred. To accurately track and record these transactions, you will need to maintain detailed financial statements and accounts.

Now in certain cases, the Income Tax Department (ITD) requires a thorough examination of these accounts to verify that they are accurately maintained and that the expenses claimed are legitimate.

This is exactly what a tax audit is.

Who conducts a tax audit?

A tax audit is carried out by a Chartered Accountant (CA), who ensures that the books of accounts and financial statements are properly maintained. The CA then includes their observations and other necessary details in the tax audit report.

Applicability of tax audit

The applicability of a tax audit depends on the turnover, sales, or gross receipts from a business or profession, along with a few specific conditions.

a) For businesses

The primary criterion is that the business turnover exceeds ₹1 crore. However, to encourage cashless transactions, the government has increased the audit threshold to ₹10 crore for businesses where more than 95% of transactions are digital.

Here’s a table to sum it up.

b) For professionals

For professionals, both turnover and profit reported are key in determining tax audit applicability.

Additionally, businesses and professionals may choose to opt for the presumptive taxation scheme, where tax audit applicability rules become a little different.

  • For businesses under presumptive taxation (u/s 44AD): A tax audit becomes mandatory if they opt out of the scheme before completing 5 years. In such cases, tax audit is required for the next 5 financial years including the year in which they opt out.

  • For professionals under presumptive taxation (u/s 44ADA): They can opt for the presumptive taxation scheme if gross receipts don’t exceed ₹75 lakh (this limit is ₹50 lakh if more than 5% of transactions are in cash). And in this case, a tax audit is not required unless they opt out of the presumptive scheme and satisfy the above listed audit conditions as in case of a normal profession.

:bulb: A tax audit is not required if total income is below the basic exemption limit.

What are the consequences of not conducting a tax audit?

If you miss the due date for filing the tax audit report, a penalty of 0.5% of turnover or gross receipts, or ₹1.5L, whichever is lower, may be imposed by the assessing officer.

Further, if you file your ITR without an audit, the return will be considered defective and a notice will be issued u/s 139(9).

Important deadlines

For taxpayers required to undergo a tax audit, the due date for filing the audit report is 30th September, and the deadline for filing the ITR is 31st October of the relevant assessment year.

Here’s a video that answers everything about tax audits.

1 Like

Let’s understand better with some examples.

  1. Ashish does intraday and F/O Trading. He has a turnover of 12 Crores and profits of 50 Lakhs. Does he require a tax audit?

    Answer: Trading in F/O and intraday segments is considered as business income and as the turnover exceeds 10 Cr, a tax audit will be applicable.

  2. Rahul runs a small retail shop and has a turnover of 8 lakhs. He incurs a loss of 2 lakhs and almost 50% of his business payments are in cash. Does he require a tax audit?

    Answer: No, Rahul does not require a tax audit. A tax audit is not mandatory because his turnover is below the threshold of 1 crore for businesses.

  3. Priya is a freelance graphic designer and has gross receipts of 15 lakhs. She has expenses of 5 lakhs. Is a tax audit applicable?

    Answer: No, Priya does not require a tax audit. Her gross receipts are below the threshold of 50 lakhs for professionals and the profit (10 lakhs) is more than 50% of the Gross receipts (15 lakhs), and a tax audit is not mandatory.

  4. Sunita is a doctor with a medical practice and earns 80 lakhs in professional fees. Is she required to get an audit done?

    Answer: Yes, Sunita requires a tax audit. Her gross professional receipts exceed 50 lakhs, and a tax audit is mandatory for professionals when their gross receipts cross this limit.

  5. Ravi runs a small construction business and initially opted for the presumptive taxation scheme u/s 44AD. After 3 years, he decided to opt out of the scheme as his business grew. However, it has been only 2 years since he opted out. Does he require a tax audit?

    Answer: Yes, Ravi requires a tax audit. Although he opted out of the presumptive taxation scheme under Section 44AD, he has not completed 5 years since he made that switch. According to the tax regulations, if you have opted into the scheme and then opted out within 5 years, you can not opt for the presumptive taxation scheme for the next 5 years and have to get a tax audit done.

Still, have doubts? Ask away!

2 Likes

Hii
If in PY Turnover exceeds 2cr but not more than 10cr, and all cash payments and Receipts are below 5%.But we cannot opt Presumptive scheme under sec 44AD and and actual profit is Below 6%.
Can We File Normal ITR With Balance sheet and Profit and loss statement With late fee?

Hey @Adi,

Yes, you can file the ITR without an audit as the turnover is between 2CR and 10CR. However, you’ll not be able to carry forward losses, if any, in such a case.

1 Like

Okay
Thank You So Much
If Turnover is 1.90cr and Profit is Below 6% and Filled ITR with Balance sheet and Profit and Loss Statement?

Hi @Adi,

As the turnover is between 1Cr to 2CR, a tax audit will be mandatory if the cash receipts/payments exceed 5%.

Hi if we have commission income more than 20l then tax audit is applicable… which section and books need to be maintained as per 44ab

Is tax audit applicable for salaried professional earning more than 50lacs?

Hi @Dharmendra_Pundeer

No, a tax audit is not applicable in case of salary income.
However, if your income in an FY exceeds ₹50 lakhs, make sure to fill Schedule Assets & Liabilies.
Here’s a read about Who should file Schedule AL in ITR?- Learn by Quicko for your reference.

Hope this helps!

Hey @venky_venkatesh,

Commission income is reported under the head “Income from Business and Profession” as Business. Hence, the audit applicability will be determined as per the criteria for businesses, and if the turnover is below Rs. 1CR, audit will not be applicable. However, the books of accounts need to be maintained.

Hope this Clarifies!

I have done audit of Firm u/s 44AB in form 3CB ,3CD . wherein some clerical mistake is there . Now my query is . can i revise the audit report?

Hey @vds91150,

If the audit report is not accepted by the firm you can ask them to reject the same and upload the audit report again.

Revision of audit report is not allowed unless there is some strong and valid reason. Revision is allowed under following circumstances:

  1. Revision of accounts of the taxpayer
  2. Change of law with a retrospective amendment
  3. Change in the interpretation of provisions, CBDT circular, CBDT judgment, etc
  4. Technical change in system or software

Hope this helps!

if a person has F&O turnover of say 60 lacs and profit of say 35 lacs and cash payment / receipts less than 5% , then

  1. can he opt for presumptive tax
  2. is audit required for filing such return

thnaks

Hey @deepak2508,

Following are the answers to your Queries,

  1. As per section 44AD (Presumptive Taxation for business), when you have a business turnover of less than Rs. 2Cr and books of accounts are not maintained, you can report 6% of your turnover/ gross receipts as profits. However, in the case of trading income, the financials can be maintained conveniently, and hence actual profits can be reported under regular business income.

  2. Audit is not required as the turnover is less than Rs. 1Cr.

Hope this clarifies!

share fno trading turnover limit is 10 crore ! am i right ?

thanks eleborating on point 1 , if one wants to file for presumptive tax, it is legal and allowed ( with F&0 turnover of 60 lacs and profit of 35 lacs with cash receipts/paymnt less than 5% )

Hey @HIREiN,

For any business with cash payments/ receipts less than 5%, an audit is applicable when the turnover exceeds Rs. 10Cr. Hence, as f/o trading transactions are completely digital, the turnover limit for audit will be Rs. 10Cr.

Hey @deepak2508,

As mentioned previously, as per section 44AD (Presumptive Taxation for business), when you have a business turnover of less than Rs. 2Cr and books of accounts are not maintained, you can report 6% of your turnover/ gross receipts as profits. However, in the case of trading income, the books of accounts can be maintained conveniently, although there’s no law prohibiting the opting in of Presumptive scheme for trading income, we recommend disclosing actual profits under regular business income.

mam i am sking this question for theoritical purpose to better understnad the concept of presumtptive taxation… if F&O turnover is 60 lacs and profit of 35 lacs ( and cash receipt/paymnt less than 5%) then can is it legal and allowed to claim presumtive tax on this income, your answer saying that one shd disclose profits under regular business income creates a doubt where in such case presumtive tax can be taken or not

Hello @deepak2508,

The concept of Presumptive taxation scheme is to provide relief to small taxpayers from maintaining books of accounts. It allows showing a specific percent 6/8 percent of turnover as profit or actual profit whichever is higher.

In case of FnO traders, the books of accounts are easily maintained so it is recommended not to opt in for presumptive taxation. It is no where prohibited that FnO traders cannot opt for presumptive taxation.

Hope this clarifies!

1 Like