If you report the LTCG from the sale of gifted equity shares as business income, it is incorrect.
Showing FnO & Intraday as business income is correct as they are considered as business income u/s43(5) of the IT Act.
Income from Business & Profession is taxed at the applicable slab rate. If you’ve been paying 30% tax, that means your annual income exceeds ₹10 lakhs under the old regime.
Rather, if you file it correctly now showing it as Income from Capital Gains, you can save taxes, as LTCG up to ₹1 lakh is exempt and is taxed at 10%.
In this thread, your team member Yash Kaviya says that “you can shift to choosing business income (instead of capital gain) if you pursue full-time trading”.
If this is true, it means LTCG can be included under business income, right?
Yes, as correctly mentioned by Yash, one can choose to show it as a business income if the person is a full-time trader.
However, it is advisable to consult a tax expert in such a regard, as there are some provisions that need to be adhered to.
If choosing to show your full-time trading as a business, then yes, LTCG can be included under business income.?
Thank you for your prompt response. I have specific questions regarding other topics too. I have written them down and made a PDF. Should I book a meeting on this Quicko website and ask them these questions on a video call? Or any other better way like email to get the doubts cleared? Thanks
So, you can book a MEET using this link (click here) and ask a tax expert for all your queries. The tax expert shall connect with you over an online video call and get your doubts cleared.
just a quick follow-up qn on this. I have chosen to show my full-time trading as a business and hence pay LTCG tax under tax slab rate (no prob even if 30%)
If I decide to sell my gifted shares and incur LTCG, then this LTCG is still to be shown as capital gain (10% tax above 1Lak) and the self-made LTCG is to be shown as business income (tax slab rate), right?? Please give some clarity regarding this.
Yes, it will be considered as a gift from a relative. When filing your income tax return (ITR), you would need to report this gift as exempt income.
However, if you sell these shares in the future, capital gains tax will be applicable on the income received from these shares.
If I consider them as stock-in–trade, then I guess they can be treated as business income. In such a scenario, when I sell them, will the grandfathering concept (with Jan 31 2018) be applicable while calculating taxable income?
buy date & value : Jan 1 2017 and Rs.100000
sell date & value : Jul 7 2023 and Rs.300000
Jan 31, 2018 value: 300000 ( no price appreciation after Jan 31 2018)
If held for investment purposes, then taxable part of LTCG is zero I guess. But if treated as business income, what will be the taxable income? whether profits till Jan 31 2018 are exempted when treated as business income also? Thank you.
The grandfathering rule is used to determine the cost of acquisition to calculate the LTCG tax on equity shares and equity mutual funds that are listed and on which STT is paid.
Yes, if held for investment purposes, then the LTCG will be taxable after considering the grandfathering rule.
If treated as business income, the difference between the purchase price in 2017 and the sale price in 2018 will be taxable income at the slab rate.
As per the law, a gift from relatives is exempt from tax.
However, in case you sell those shares, any gains/loss will be taxable under “Capital gains” income.
You can read this thread for a better understandig.
Yes, it applies the same taxability on gifting Sovereign Gold Bonds as physical gold. And the interest on such gold bonds will be taxable under Income from Other Sources (IFOS).
Please inform where do you find the column for Gift received in money in your filing portal. I was unable to find it. Also deductions under section VI. So temporarily i have deactivated my account in Quick efiling. Please guide. The portal suggested ITR3. I am an individual and not a business organisation. Many sheets found in excel utility is missing in your portal.